How to Keep Cheese Sauce Creamy in the Fridge (And Reheat It Without Breaking)

This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated.

A silky, homemade cheese sauce is pure comfort food—but if you’ve ever stored leftovers, you’ve likely faced the dreaded day-two dilemma: it’s grainy, separated, or just plain disappointing.

Don’t worry. With a few smart techniques, you can store and reheat cheese sauce so it stays rich, smooth, and spoon-worthy the next day.

Jump ahead to:

🧀 Can You Store Cheese Sauce in the Fridge?

Yes, absolutely. But the key is how you store it.

✅ Tips for Storing Cheese Sauce Properly:

Let it cool to room temperature before refrigerating
Store it in an airtight glass or BPA-free container
Press a layer of parchment or plastic wrap directly on the surface to prevent a skin from forming
Label with the date—cheese sauce keeps well for up to 3–4 days

🧂 Pro Tip: Avoid storing it in the saucepan—it cools unevenly and makes separation more likely.

🔥 Reheating Cheese Sauce Without Breaking It

The mistake most people make? Microwaving it cold, full blast.

✅ The Gentle Reheat Method (My Go-To Fix):

Let it come to room temperature for 10–15 minutes
In a saucepan, warm 2–3 tablespoons of milk or cream over low heat
Add the cold cheese sauce in spoonfuls, whisking gently
Heat slowly, stirring constantly until smooth and glossy again

🎯 Low and slow is the secret—if you see steam or bubbling, your heat’s too high.

🥄 Need to Fix a Grainy Reheat?

If the texture starts to separate:

Whisk in 1 tsp lemon juice or cream to help re-emulsify
Keep stirring until it smooths back out

🧠 Note: Don’t add both lemon and cream—use one or the other.

🧁 Bonus: Reheating Mac & Cheese Made With Cheese Sauce

Mac and cheese tends to dry out in the fridge. Here’s how to bring it back to life:

Let it sit at room temp for 20 minutes
Warm a splash of whole milk or cream in a pan
Add your mac and cheese, stir gently
Optional: Place in oven-safe bowl, top with cheese or breadcrumbs, and bake at 325°F for 10–15 minutes

🧂 Pro Tip: Add extra shredded cheese when reheating to refresh texture and flavor

🧊 Can You Freeze Cheese Sauce?

Technically yes, but the texture usually suffers. The fats and proteins often separate during freezing and thawing.

If you do freeze it:

Let it cool fully
Store in a flat, airtight freezer bag
Thaw slowly in the fridge
Reheat using the milk + whisk method above

Final Thoughts

Cheese sauce doesn’t have to be a one-day treat. With a little care—cooling it right, storing it smart, and reheating it gently—you can enjoy creamy, dreamy cheese sauce again and again.

Want to learn how to fix a grainy cheese sauce before it even hits the fridge? Read: How to Fix Grainy Cheese Sauce (And Keep It Creamy Next Time)

Also See:

Anne James

Anne James—also known as Jelly Grandma—is a professional canner and lifelong food preserver with over 55 years of hands-on experience. A retired librarian, paralegal, and self-taught expert in traditional Southern crafts, Anne specializes in canning, jelly-making, cooking, gardening, and quilting. She even has extensive experience as a bartender.
She’s been featured in the Daily Commercial and on Hershey’s website, and is lovingly known as the “go-to canner” in her family and beyond. Her mission is simple: to preserve and pass on the old ways—skills that kept generations thriving without shortcuts or preservatives.
You can find more of Anne’s work at PreservingSweetness.com, on YouTube, and occasionally on SurvivalFreedom.com.